madstah's art Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Hidden Orchestra.]

Good

She should be closer to viewer, becuse she is the most important object on picture, but because she is in the middle you first see some trees, leafs, birds/butterflies and then her. It should be reverse :)

Kuoke responds:

Subject priority is arguable.

[Holy Crab!!]

The last one

That last one "Purple Tentacle (c) Maniac Mansion" looks almost the same as the monster from a very old game "Day of the Tentacle". Brings good memories from the good old times :)

JinnPixel responds:

It's the same monster! Maniac Mansion came first, you should play it too! :)

[What the...]

poor

first he is a homo, second its poor, third lol

Artyluck responds:

Huh?

[Spiders]

2 hours?!

man it's great and even better if you really made it in only 2 hours

Kamikaye responds:

Yea thx , well I had to have a deeep grip into the trick chest :D

[A cup of coffee, yes?]

hmm nice but...

...lol this shouldn't be here, because it's a basic 3d object that i learn at school lol i can make hundreds of these, so sorry, nice render but it's like drawing a few sticks on a paper and adding shadow to them, because the program does everything for you. I bet it took you about 20 minutes MAX + rendering time

SimonG responds:

I really don't go to a school like you, and I learn stuff myself...
But it's fun, and sometimes, it's not about the complexity of the model, but the overall feel... Something like that.
But thanks for the review :)

[An Hero]

Nice

I'll speak in polish :)

Z wszystkich Twoich prac ten koles jest najlepszy chyba, podobaja mi sie szczegoly typu owlosienie rak i ozdobki szaty itd, miecz tez calkiem niezle wyszedl, ale za grube kontury i za bardzo poszarpane, gdyby nie to byl by zajebisty pewnie, a tak btw to napisz mi w jakim programie to wykonales, bo dymek z faji mozna ladnie zrobic w PSie

Van-pl responds:

Coz, namalowalem w PS-ie :P Nie znam sie jednak na programie, wystarczaja mi standardowe brushe plus czasem zaznaczanie i efekty. Co do lineartu to wlasnie o cos takiego chodzilo, nie chcialem zeby gosc wygladal jak zniewiescialy frajer z mangi dla 13-latek.

Zreszta holduje zasade ze bardziej liczy sie przekaz i tresc niz forma.

No i staraj sie szprechac po angielsku, zeby inni rowniez mieli pojecie o czym gadamy ;)

[Remains]

What is this?

I know you wanted to show something in this picture, but i really can't see what it is, I only see 2 guys that are just about to get hit by big wave or like somebody below said, by big red fist :D

Maybe it's because I lack the artist viewpoint, but I think you could work at it a bit more

idiot-monarch responds:

lol, those are cliffs not waves